Shark Fishing Banned in the Red Sea

HEPCA (the Hurghada Environmental Protection and Conservation Association) has become a force to be reckoned with, with the recently issued decree that will finally ban shark fishing in the Red Sea marking a significant victory for the NGO.

"We are making more and more enemies every day. In our business, that’s the ultimate sign of success," says Amr Ali, HEPCA’s outspoken managing director.

Still basking in the glow of his most recent conquest, which now arms him with the legislative means to put a stop to the dozens of shark massacres that are reported daily throughout Egypt’s Red Sea coastline from Hurghada to Marsa Alam, Ali is confident that the fishing and trading of sharks in Egypt will come to an end or at the very least be heavily curtailed.

The Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries decree came with strong backing from the Red Sea National Park’s Dr. Mahmoud Hanafy.

"When it comes to environmental violations of any sort it is usually not a problem of a lack of laws but rather contradictions in existing laws that keeps us from being able to move forward," explains Ali.

Shark fishing has, theoretically, been illegal since 1973, when Egypt became one of 100 countries to sign the CITES (Convention of International Trading of Endangered Species) Treaty. Sharks in the Red Sea were on CITES’ list of endangered species, but the Egyptian law that regulates fishing made no mention of sharks.

Technically, fishermen who were catching and trading in sharks could not be criminally prosecuted.

According to Ali, the problem began to reach alarming levels in 2000, when divers and conservationists started noticing a marked decrease in shark populations. The decline in numbers was mainly attributed to an increase in the number of fishing boats in the Red Sea.

"Fishermen from the Delta were moving into the Red Sea. Unfamiliar with the territory and its ecosystem, they were employing fishing techniques that were harming everything from the sharks to the corals," says Ali.

This new wave of commercial fishing, coupled with the rise of a handful of trading companies that were being established solely for the purpose of exporting in-demand seafood delicacies (including sea cucumbers and shark fins) to the Chinese market, were an environmental catastrophe in the making.

"The Red Sea has a very delicate ecosystem. Any disturbance in that system, whether it’s a drop in the number of sharks (the top of the food chain) or in the smaller fish that they prey upon, will wreak havoc on one of our most precious natural resources, the coral reef," says diving instructor Sherif Taher.

"Sharks are a valuable source of revenue for the country. Many people don’t realize that tourists spend millions of dollars in the Red Sea because of the sharks. For example, a dive destination like the Brother Islands (off the coast of Marsa Alam) is sold primarily because of its abundant shark population. It has been estimated that each shark in the Red Sea generates approximately 10,000 pounds sterling in income to the country," says Ali.

It is difficult to quantify Egypt’s current shark population and how much it has suffered over the years, but divers claim that sites near Sharm El-Sheikh and Hurghada that have always been known as prime shark viewing destinations are becoming less and less inhabited with by sharks.

"This is not only the consequence of the lucrative shark fin trade, it also has to do with the overdevelopment of our resorts," says Taher.

The international environmental NGO Greenpeace claims that a whopping 100 million sharks are illegally killed around the world each year. HEPCA has been actively trying to put a stop to the killings in the Red Sea for the past five years, but in the absence of a national law there was little that could be done.
"Sharks are a valuable source of revenue for the country. Many people don’t realize that tourists spend millions of dollars in the Red Sea because of the sharks. For example, a dive destination like the Brother Islands (off the coast of Marsa Alam) is sold primarily because of its abundant shark population. It has been estimated that each shark in the Red Sea generates approximately 10,000 pounds sterling in income to the country," says Ali.

It is difficult to quantify Egypt’s current shark population and how much it has suffered over the years, but divers claim that sites near Sharm El-Sheikh and Hurghada that have always been known as prime shark viewing destinations are becoming less and less inhabited with by sharks.

"This is not only the consequence of the lucrative shark fin trade, it also has to do with the overdevelopment of our resorts," says Taher.

The international environmental NGO Greenpeace claims that a whopping 100 million sharks are illegally killed around the world each year. HEPCA has been actively trying to put a stop to the killings in the Red Sea for the past five years, but in the absence of a national law there was little that could be done.

The first positive step came in 2004, when Red Sea Governor Gen. Saad Abu Rida ordered a ban.

"This allowed us to start catching and fining those responsible for the shark massacres that were occurring on a daily basis,” says Ali.

"We were being tipped off by HEPCA members and dive boat captains all over the coast about perpetrators. We would go to the sites and find gruesome scenes of shark carcasses, amputated fins and nets full of up to 20 sharks that were caught in one go. Once we even came across a captured pregnant tiger shark with 12 young shark pups inside her belly," explains Ali.

Fines and penalties of up to LE 100,000 were slapped on fishermen and traders, but clever lawyers were often able to maneuver their clients out of paying the penalties on the grounds that the National Fishing Law did not forbid shark fishing.

Under mounting pressure and lobbying from HEPCA and the Red Sea Governorate, the government passed a decree in August 2005 that officially banned and criminalized shark fishing and trading in Egypt.

"This was a historic decision on the part of Dr. Ezzat Awad, the head of the General Authority for the Development of Fishing Resources," says Ali.

"We are very pleased that he has taken such an active interest in the environmental problems of the Red Sea. Conservationists worldwide have applauded the decision," adds Ali.

The shark fishing law along with an earlier legislation that was passed to forbid net fishing on or near the coral reefs are considered to be two of the most significant steps forward in the history of Red Sea conservation.

As HEPCA’s list of recent victories (including saving Giftun Island and putting a stop to the destruction of a valuable coral reef at the Kahramana Hotel in Marsa Alam) continues to grow, the group is gaining international attention as well as local clout.

The achievements are remarkable for an organization that originated in 1990 with a humble group of divers who took it upon themselves to collect money and install 100 mooring buoys in Hurghada.